Menu
EN

The new ‘pay or consent’ scheme in media: a costly illusion of choice

This year several UK newspapers began implementing a ‘pay or consent’ model, asking readers to pay if they want to avoid personalized advertising. If you think this is just more newspapers jumping on the paywall trend, don’t be fooled. The real catch is in the word “personalized” — even if you pay for a subscription, you’ll still see ads; they just won’t be targeted to you.

Among the major players that have embraced this scheme is The Sun, which asks for £4.99 a month, followed by The Independent at £4, and Mail Online at £2.70. Other publishers like Reach, which includes the Mirror and Express, are offering a “Privacy Plus” option for £1.99.

Most of the newspapers offer only a limited ads experience. The Independent stands out by providing an ad-free experience for its paid subscribers, but it is more of an exception than the rule.

Mail Online ‘pay or consent’ message

The model is not exclusive to Britain and it’s not Britain that started the trend. Several German newspapers, such as Bild, adopted the scheme before their British counterparts.

However, its growing popularity and adoption in the UK puts it in the spotlight, especially since there is a chance it could spread further throughout Europe and, who knows, become a staple globally — particularly in countries where privacy laws have been on the rise.

A closer look at the offers

The implementation by various British newspapers (which we will focus on for the purpose of this article, as they provide a good sample size) varies. Some cut straight to the chase, offering readers a choice between accepting personalized ads or paying to prevent a website from tracking them immediately. Others display lengthy messages, making readers jump through several hoops and prompting them to consent to personalized advertising multiple times before finally presenting the ‘reject all’ option and requesting compensation.

One of the less convoluted routes is presented by the Sun, which immediately asks you either to pay to reject personalized ads or consent to them.

The Sun ‘pay or consent’ message

In contrast, Express makes it a little bit more difficult for readers to reject personalized advertising. The first notice prompts users to click ‘accept,’ and if they choose ‘more options’ instead, they’ll encounter a lengthy message explaining what types of information Express plans to share and with whom if the user accepts the personalized advertising terms.

Express privacy notice

That notice is a treasure trove of information by itself. From it, an inquisitive enough user might learn that if you click “accept all,” it will share your personal information, such as unique identifiers, with as many as 1147 (!) of Express’s partners.

Detailed Express privacy notice

If you’re still not sold on the idea of having your personal data used to build your profile for personalized advertising — done by as many as 512 of Express’s partners — or allowing 690 of them to store and/or access information on your device, you’re finally presented with an option to opt out of tracking and personalized ads for £1.99. However, even at this point, Express isn’t giving up on its quest to gather data for personalized advertising, reminding users once again that there’s an option to go “back to consent.” The tabloid’s relentless push for tracking suggests that it might be more profitable to keep collecting data for ads rather than just collecting the fee.

Express’s last ‘consent’ reminder

Alternatively, you can manually go through the notice and adjust your preferences from off to on, but let’s be real — most people will probably just hit ‘accept all’ without even looking at the options.

The unattractive choice of the lesser evil

This new scheme presents readers with a seemingly simple choice: pay for a reduced ad experience or accept personalized ads (and very rarely go completely ad-free). The devil is in the wording. The Daily Mail makes it clear that the Mail Essential subscription will only offer you the option of being tracked slightly less — it’s only ‘reduced tracking,’ not ‘no tracking.’ The website will still use cookies “and similar technologies” to provide its services and “for other purposes, including personalized content, measurement, audience research, and services development.”

The Daily Mail Essential notice

Similarly with ads. You will still see ads, they will just be non-personalized.

The Daily Mail personalized ads notice

Publishers explain that this is a fair value exchange: by paying to avoid personalized ads, readers fund high-quality journalism, since personalized, highly targeted ads are known to be much more effective than generalized advertising.

However, this raises an important question: is this value exchange really fair?
In our opinion, the fairness of this arrangement is highly questionable. Paying to hide some ads (not all ads even) is hardly a compelling value proposition, especially when there is not even an option to go completely ad-free. In our view, it’s just a different iteration of advertising. And we believe that most users will reject it, even if there were indeed a genuine choice. Our recent survey commissioned through Survey Monkey indicated that most users would prefer to use ad blockers rather than pay for ad-free content.

Moreover, while the fees for opting out of personalized advertising might seem manageable for a single website, consider the implications if every site adopts this model. This choice becomes unsustainable, especially if it only leads to fewer ads or a different type of advertising. Moreover, the technology for tracking will still be embedded in these sites, meaning users remain vulnerable to surveillance.

Data privacy concerns

A big concern is what happens to the data collected before users opt out or buy a subscription, and after they cancel the subscription. The uncertainty around data retention creates serious privacy issues. Users might unknowingly create a digital footprint that sticks around, even if they later decide to withdraw consent.

This raises serious questions about how clear and honest companies are when it comes to handling data. Consumers are left feeling uneasy about what their choices really mean, especially in a situation that often feels like it’s taking advantage of them.

The regulatory backdrop or what made this scheme possible?

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), the independent body overseeing data protection in the UK, has suggested that this model fits within data protection laws, meaning consent-based pricing could be allowed.

However, the ICO also emphasized that consent has to be “freely given” and “fully informed,” which raises some red flags considering the fees and the limitations of the subscriptions involved. As publishers scramble to boost consent rates amid falling ad revenues, the real integrity of user choice is at risk.

In short, while the pay or consent model claims to give readers more power, it ultimately creates an illusion of choice that could hurt consumer trust and the future of journalism. Many users would rather stick with ad blockers than pay for a service that doesn’t fully meet their needs.

Liked this post?
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for Windows

AdGuard for Windows is more than an ad blocker. It is a multipurpose tool that blocks ads, controls access to dangerous sites, speeds up page loading, and protects children from inappropriate content.
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for Mac

AdGuard for Mac is a unique ad blocker designed with macOS in mind. In addition to protecting you from annoying ads in browsers and apps, it shields you from tracking, phishing, and fraud.
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for Android

AdGuard for Android is a perfect solution for Android devices. Unlike most other ad blockers, AdGuard doesn't require root access and provides a wide range of app management options.
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for iOS

The best iOS ad blocker for iPhone and iPad. AdGuard eliminates all kinds of ads in Safari, protects your privacy, and speeds up page loading. AdGuard for iOS ad-blocking technology ensures the highest quality filtering and allows you to use multiple filters at the same time
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard VPN

74 locations worldwide

Access to any content

Strong encryption

No-logging policy

Fastest connection

24/7 support

Try for free
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Content Blocker

AdGuard Content Blocker will eliminate all kinds of ads in mobile browsers that support content blocker technology — namely, Samsung Internet and Yandex.Browser. While being more limited than AdGuard for Android, it is free, easy to install and still provides high ad blocking quality.
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Browser Extension

AdGuard is the fastest and most lightweight ad blocking extension that effectively blocks all types of ads on all web pages! Choose AdGuard for the browser you use and get ad-free, fast and safe browsing.
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Assistant

A companion browser extension for AdGuard desktop apps. It offers an in-browser access to such features as custom element blocking, allowlisting a website or sending a report.
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard DNS

AdGuard DNS is a foolproof way to block Internet ads that does not require installing any applications. It is easy to use, absolutely free, easily set up on any device, and provides you with minimal necessary functions to block ads, counters, malicious websites, and adult content.
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Home

AdGuard Home is a network-wide software for blocking ads & tracking. After you set it up, it’ll cover ALL your home devices, and you don’t need any client-side software for that. With the rise of Internet-Of-Things and connected devices, it becomes more and more important to be able to control your whole network.
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Pro for iOS

AdGuard Pro has much to offer on top of the excellent iOS ad blocking in Safari already known to the users of the regular version. By providing access to custom DNS settings, the app allows you to block ads, protect your kids from adult content online, and safeguard your personal data from theft.
By downloading the program you accept the terms of the License agreement
Read more
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for Safari

Ad blocking extensions for Safari are having hard time since Apple started to force everyone to use the new SDK. AdGuard extension is supposed to bring back the high quality ad blocking back to Safari.
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard Temp Mail

A free temporary email address generator that keeps you anonymous and protects your privacy. No spam in your main inbox!
18,367 18367 user reviews
Excellent!

AdGuard for Android TV

AdGuard for Android TV is the only app that blocks ads, guards your privacy, and acts as a firewall for your Smart TV. Get warnings about web threats, use secure DNS, and benefit from encrypted traffic. Relax and dive into your favorite shows with top-notch security and zero ads!
Downloading AdGuard To install AdGuard, click the file indicated by the arrow Select "Open" and click "OK", then wait for the file to be downloaded. In the opened window, drag the AdGuard icon to the "Applications" folder. Thank you for choosing AdGuard! Select "Open" and click "OK", then wait for the file to be downloaded. In the opened window, click "Install". Thank you for choosing AdGuard!
Install AdGuard on your mobile device